Upcoming Events

Where the Cloud Touches Down: Simplifying Data Center Infrastructure Management

Thursday, July 25, 2013
10:00 AM PT/1:00 PM ET

In most data centers, DCIM rests on a shaky foundation of manual record keeping and scattered documentation. OpManager replaces data center documentation with a single repository for data, QRCodes for asset tracking, accurate 3D mapping of asset locations, and a configuration management database (CMDB). In this webcast, sponsored by ManageEngine, you will see how a real-world datacenter mapping stored in racktables gets imported into OpManager, which then provides a 3D visualization of where assets actually are. You'll also see how the QR Code generator helps you make the link between real assets and the monitoring world, and how the layered CMDB provides a single point of view for all your configuration data.

Register Now!

A Network Computing Webinar:
SDN First Steps

Thursday, August 8, 2013
11:00 AM PT / 2:00 PM ET

This webinar will help attendees understand the overall concept of SDN and its benefits, describe the different conceptual approaches to SDN, and examine the various technologies, both proprietary and open source, that are emerging. It will also help users decide whether SDN makes sense in their environment, and outline the first steps IT can take for testing SDN technologies.

Register Now!

More Events »

Subscribe to Newsletter

  • Keep up with all of the latest news and analysis on the fast-moving IT industry with Network Computing newsletters.
Sign Up

Review: Vidyo Video-Conferencing

Vidyo provides a family of video-conferencing products that are designed to use the Internet rather than a private WAN to connect video-conferencing systems. Vidyo's product line includes a room system, VidyoRoom, as well as a PC client, gateway-to-SIP and H.323 devices, as well as a friendly administrative system. Vidyo uses off-the-shelf cameras and microphones that you can purchase anywhere. We tested VidyoRoom and several PC clients at Hippensteel Labs.

Vidyo competes with major vendors such as Cisco and Polycom. While Vidyo makes products for businesses of all sizes, we think it is most appropriate for companies with congested or overworked WANs. For large installations, the company recommends you run its compression engine, the VidyoRouter, and its administrative software on separate servers. The VidyoRouter and administration software are available on a single appliance for smaller installations.

Vidyo builds on the H.264 SVC standard. Unlike competitors such as Polycom, Tandberg and others that use H.264 AVC, Vidyo chose SVC because it was developed specifically to allow for transport networks such as the Internet that might introduce variable conditions, including jitter and packet loss.

To address variable conditions, Vidyo divides the video stream into three sub-streams: base, level one and level two. The base stream contains enough information to provide a low-resolution image at a low frame rate. The other two streams refine that image into the desired output, such as 720p HD to produce an excellent picture. All three streams are delivered when network conditions are good. If network conditions deteriorate, the system reduces delivery of the level-two stream, and if necessary, the level-one stream. This adjustment takes place in a few hundred milliseconds, so users rarely notice the change. Since most network deterioration is short-lived, the lower resolution is likewise temporary and good picture quality is quick to return.

We connected the VidyoRoom system with an HD camera to five PCs of varying capabilities. One PC used Wifi. Then we used a PacketStorm emulator to introduce various levels of network impairments to simulate the unpredictable conditions of the Internet. The Vidyo system worked so well that several technicians involved in the test didn't realize that impairments had been introduced. A summary of some of our results is shown in Table 1. There was no noticeable degradation in output at the end points at either one percent or three percent packet loss. We believe this simulation would account for a very high percentage of the Internet connections your users might experience.

Our Take
For day-to-day business conferences, Vidyo's system is functional, well designed and cost effective.
The system shows its best capability in highly heterogeneous and hybrid wired and wireless environments.
It supports a variety of end-points, from desktops to laptops to mobile devices.

Other video-conferencing systems we've tested show acceptable output at the same levels of packet loss, but their desktop clients suffer from increased processing strain. As a result, the video suffers from delay. By contrast, with Vidyo, we introduced high levels of jitter (up to 30 ms) and the quality of the sound and video didn't appear to deteriorate. In our experience, jitter is the nemesis of competing video-conferencing systems; even 10 ms. of jitter causes some systems to seriously degrade.

If you're looking for a video-conferencing system to impress executives or business partners, Vidyo may not be for you, as it uses off-the-shelf components while competitors offer high-end, wrap-around screens and sophisticated microphone systems. However, for day-to-day business communication, Vidyo is functional, well-designed and cost-effective.

VidyoRoom Endpoint Performance Under Network Impairments
Loss (%)Jitter (ms)
3ExcellentExcellentVery Good
5ExcellentVery GoodVery Good
10ExcellentVery GoodVery Good
Vidyo endpoints performed well even as we introduced packet loss and jitter. Jitter often trips up other video-conferencing systems, but even with high levels of jitter we noticed very little degradation of picture and sound quality. Excellent quality means no noticeable distortion. Very good means slight distortion.

Vidyo is ideal for organizations with users that have a variety of end-points, from desktop PCs to laptops, netbooks and even mobile devices. In addition, the system is a good fit for companies that run a hybrid wired/wireless environment. Vidyo offers a starter package for $7,000. It includes all of the infrastructure and perpetually licensed software necessary to deploy desktop video-conferencing to 75 administered users and the ability to host up to five concurrent multi-point connections. For larger organizations, pricing is negotiable. (Phil Hippensteel is an assistant professor of information systems at Penn State and an industry consultant.)

Related Reading

More Insights

Network Computing encourages readers to engage in spirited, healthy debate, including taking us to task. However, Network Computing moderates all comments posted to our site, and reserves the right to modify or remove any content that it determines to be derogatory, offensive, inflammatory, vulgar, irrelevant/off-topic, racist or obvious marketing/SPAM. Network Computing further reserves the right to disable the profile of any commenter participating in said activities.

Disqus Tips To upload an avatar photo, first complete your Disqus profile. | Please read our commenting policy.
Vendor Comparisons
Network Computing’s Vendor Comparisons provide extensive details on products and services, including downloadable feature matrices. Our categories include:

Research and Reports

Network Computing: April 2013

TechWeb Careers